Skip to main content

Galloping

Updated today

Galloping of conductors is where conductors oscillate in large, low-frequency movements caused by wind and ice conditions. Unlike smaller vibrations, galloping involves dramatic swaying motions that can span several meters in amplitude. Galloping poses serious risks to power infrastructure in the form of conductor clashing and equipment failure. Modeling of this behavior is done by calculating the swept area, or ellipse, that a galloping conductor occupies. Ellipses can then be analyzed to determine if there are clearance violations, such as ellipses intersection or overlap.


Platform Capability

Neara allows users to complete galloping analysis to assess the ellipses created by conductors as well as clearance violations between ellipses including ellipse overlap. The set up for this has some complexity so a Module has been created to improve simplicity and allow users to conduct analysis quickly and simply.

Using the module allows users to interact with galloping via a purpose built panel and two reports.

Galloping assessments are completed using Finite Element Analysis (FEA). For more information about FEA, see Finite Element Analysis.

Project set up

There are a few set up steps that need to be completed as follows.

Importing the module

If you are unable to use modules, contact your Customer Success Manager or our support team via the in app Help menu.

  1. Select (+) from any section on the workspace and select Modules from the Tools section of the panels menu.

  2. Select + Import Org Module in the top left corner.

  3. Select the check box for Galloping and click Import module(s)

The module title will appear in the sidebar and once selected the details including Key and Namespace will be displayed.

Set up environments

Galloping must complete a sag calculation and a blowout calculation. In order to do this, two environments must be established in the Environments menu:

  1. Blowout

  2. Sag

For example:

Environment

Wire Temp (°C)

Wind pressure (Pa)

Radial ice (mm)

Ice density (kg/m³)

Blowout

0

95.8

12.5

912

Sag

0

0

12.5

912

For more information about Environments, see Modify an Environment.

Note: Environment names and descriptions do not have to conform to the above. It is recommended these are unique and easy to understand as users will need to configure which environment the galloping assessment should use for the sag calculation and which for the blowout calculation.

Open user panel

To open the galloping user panel select (+) from any section on the workspace and then select gallop~Galloping User Panel from the User Panels section of the menu.

The panel contains 3 main sections:

  1. Configuration

  2. Results Summary

  3. Reports

Configuration

Option

Details

Galloping method

Method to be applied when calculating gallop

  • For more information about the methods, see below

Blowout environment

Environment to be used for blowout calculation

Sag environment

Environment to be used for sag calculation

Safety validation method

Method of validating conductor safety in terms of galloping, options:

  • Clearance distance - distance between ellipses

  • Overlap percentage - percentage of ellipses overlap

Clearance violation limit

Distance between ellipses at/under which a violation occurs

Note: appears if Safety validation method is set to Clearance distance

Overlap violation limit %

Percentage overlap of ellipses at/over which a violation occurs

Note: appears if Safety validation method is set to Overlap percentage

FEA simulation

Type of FEA simulation used to calculate galloping ellipse, options:

  • Network solve

  • Ruling span

Visualize ellipses

Control visualization of ellipses in view panels

Visualize blowout conductors

Control visualization of conductor blowout in view panels

Visualize clearance distance

Control visualization of clearance distance between closest ellipse pairs in view panels

Wind direction

Perpendicular wind direction to be applied to conductors, options:

  • A

  • B

If fields have not been configured satisfactorily warnings will appear, including if a blowout environment does not have any wind applied.

Results summary

This provides an overview of the report results. For more detail, refer to the reports.

Option

Details

Overall Pass / Fail

Overview of whether all conductors pass (✅) or fail (❌) the configured safety violation limit

Span stack failure count

Number of span stacks that contain ellipses that exceed the configured safety violation limit

Span stack pass count

Number of span stacks that contain ellipses that do not exceed the configured safety violation limit

Reports

Open galloping reports from the user panel using the links.

Galloping overview provides a row per span stack and advises:

  • Poles the span stack is between

  • Highest voltage within the stack

  • Span length being the horizontal distance between attachment points

  • Worst clearance between ellipses

  • Worst overlap of ellipses

  • Overall stack pass/fail

Galloping breakdown provides a row per conductor and advises:

  • Span label which will be shared by conductors in the span

  • Cable index for the conductor

  • Worst clearance for the conductor under each wind condition

  • Worst overlap for the conductor under each wind condition

  • Conductor pass/fail

  • Ellipse visualization

  • Blowout visualization

Clearance Visualization provides a row per span stack and advises:

  • Clearance distance visualization


Methodology Overview

Ellipse geometry is defined by the following parameters.

Major axis

Vertical magnitude of the galloping ellipse

Minor axis

Horizontal magnitude of the galloping ellipse

Sag

Vertical distance between the highest and the lowest point of the conductor

  • Note: maximum sag along the catenary is used

B

Distance between the bottom of the ellipse and the attach point along the catenary

SSW

Blowout angle of the catenary with respect to the vertical

ESW

Tilt angle of the ellipse with respect to the vertical

Available methodologies

Users can now select from three galloping ellipse calculation methodologies via the Galloping UI.

Note: the Cigre methodology contains two variations, bundled and unbundled. The appropriate methodology will be automatically applied based on whether the conductors under assessment are bundled or unbundled.

RUS Bulletin - Single loop (RUS Bulletin 1724E-200)

  • Evaluates overlap at the midpoint of the conductor

RUS Bulletin - Double loop (RUS Bulletin 1724E-200)

  • Creates ellipses at 0.25 and 0.75 along the conductor where 0 is the start of the conductor and 1 is the end of the conductor

  • The overlap calculation checks the overlap of ellipses at 0.25 and 0.75 and returns whichever is highest

Cigre

There are two variations for this methodology based on whether the conductors are bundled or unbundled.

Bundled

  • Evaluates overlap at the midpoint of the conductor

  • Uses the diameter of the inner/sub conductor (DIA)

  • This method sets tilt angle to 0 degrees

Note: this method will produce an error for spans with very small sag values as the large denominator coefficient yields a near-zero argument for the ln() function, preventing a valid result. The error will advise the current sag value as well as the minimum sag required to remove the error.

Unbundled

  • Evaluates overlap at the midpoint of the conductor

  • Uses the diameter of the conductor (DIA)

  • This method sets tilt angle to 0 degrees

Galloping Functions

There are two main functions used to establish galloping, each taking a number of arguments.

calculate_gallop(strain_section: …, blowout_catenary: …, sag_catenary: …, method: …)

  • This function is used to calculate gallop using the specified inbuilt method.

  • The arguments required are:

    • strain_section: Strain section on which the galloping occurs

    • blowout_catenary: Catenary derived from the strain section in the blowout environment.

      • This is accessed from simulate_strain_section_fea(...).SpanReports[].CableReports[].catenary

    • sag_catenary: Catenary derived from the strain section in the sag environment.

      • This is accessed from simulate_strain_section_fea(...).SpanReports[].CableReports[].catenary

    • method: Galloping method to be used to calculate the galloping ellipse.

      • The options available are

        • RUS single loop

        • RUS double loop

        • Cigre bundled

        • Cigre unbundled

calculate_gallop_clearance(gallopingEllipses)

  • This function is used to calculate the overlap of galloping ellipses.

  • It determines the GallopingClashPairs, i.e. all the pairs of overlapping galloping ellipses that can be made on the current span, and compiles these into a list in GallopingClashResult

  • The results can be drilled into using .worst

    • .worst.ClashPairs gives the pair of ellipses with the highest overlap ratio

    • .worst.ClashPairs[].overlapRatio gives the pair of ellipses with the highest overlap ratio and presents the percentage overlap of that pair

    • .worst.ClashPairs[].clearance gives the pair of ellipses with the lowest clearance and presents the distance between the ellipses

      • Note this cannot be negative.

    • .worst.ClashPairs[].ellipse1 or .worst.ClashPairs[].ellipse2, provides insight into which ellipses on the span are experiencing high overlap

Module foundation

The galloping functions require a range of fields and collections to be established and then configured. This is not a simple process so the module has been established to make it easier for users to use the galloping capability without having to complete complex set up.

The set up contained in the module is as follows with many fields utilizing _a and _b variants to return separate results based on the selected perpendicular wind direction:

  1. Define a collection of cables on the span so that simulations and calculations are completed on individual conductors.

    1. Span_c_cables

  2. Simulate catenaries of cables within a strain section under blowout and sag conditions using Finite Element Analysis.

    1. u_blowout_fea and u_sag_fea uses the function simulate_strain_section_fea()

  3. Filter for appropriate catenary of cable based on span, cable index, and wind direction.

    1. u_blowout_catenary and u_sag_catenary

  4. Define the strain section each cable is on as it will be needed when calculating gallop.

    1. u_strain_section

  5. Use the sag and blowout catenaries, the strain section cable is a part of, and galloping method to calculate galloping ellipse of each cable

    1. u_galloping_ellipse

  6. Collate all galloping ellipses of a span stack into a list

    1. u_galloping_ellipses

  7. Use galloping ellipses of a span stack to calculate the clash pairs that could clash and their overlap ratio

    1. u_galloping_ellipses


Troubleshooting

No results in report

  • Check Environments have been set up correctly as specified in Set up environments.

  • Check for any warnings in the Galloping User Panel.

    • All of the fields should be populated with valid selections from the dropdown menus.

Failed FEA solves

  • Trigger rerunning of FEA by updating FEA configuration as follows:

    • Select (+) from any section on the workspace and select FEA from the Tools section of the panels menu.

    • In the Simulation section of the FEA panel click the Clear runs button

    • Return to the Galloping User Panel

    • In the FEA Simulation Type dropdown, update the selection

      • If Network solve was selected, switch to Ruling span.

      • If Ruling span was selected, switch to Network solve.

    • Wait for FEA simulation to run

    • Update FEA Simulation Type dropdown to the preferred FEA Simulation Type

Empty cells / errors for Cigre method

For Cigre method, if the cells in the Galloping Breakdown report relating to bundled conductors are empty, the sag may be too small which means the calculation is invalid and will not return a value.

  • Check the Galloping Overview report for the following warning:

    • ⚠️ Expr Eval Error: Invalid argument(s): Sag value X is too small for Cigre bundled method.

  • To remove this warning sag must be increased.

    • E.g. increase span length or reduce tension.

Did this answer your question?